Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you buy an item through one of those affiliate links, Successible Life may get a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps keep the blog running so we can continue to provide you with the best content.
Since time immemorial, we ladies have loved our beauty products but ESPECIALLY the ones for our lashes. Can you guess how old mascara is? Well, let’s just say that Cleopatra wasn’t the first to wear it! In fact, the ancient Egyptians made their mascara out of stone compounds to achieve its dark and distinctive color. Of course, modern cosmetics companies have made leaps and bounds since then in their formulation, but some good old-fashioned mascara is still THE product of choice to complete the perfect makeup look in the way it frames your eyes. And with all that noteworthy progress, today we’ll be talking about some of the best waterproof mascara products around!
Let’s face it: waterproof mascara is a product of choice not just because of its convenience but also its durability. Even if you’re not by the water or in a rainy environment, the stuff seems to stay on forever. But that’s also part of the downside – waterproof mascara gets its share of backlash and regret. The same ingredients that help it resist water can also cause your lashes to become brittle and even fall out. Also, it’s hard to find a makeup remover that really gets off your waterproof mascara completely once you want to be done with it. So is it still worth it?
Well, let’s first make a comparison of mascara in general to one of its chief rivals: fake lashes. While fake lashes can look oh-so-good once you get them on, there’s an obvious danger of having foreign objects so close to your eyes. Second off, removing fake lashes can be equally dangerous…to the point that they can rip out your natural hair follicles permanently. And finally, if you don’t keep your fake lashes squeaky clean, there’s a sizeable chance of getting an eye infection once you put them back on. So clearly, mascara is the winner in that contest. But is waterproof mascara also worth it with its potential downsides? Read on, and you’ll see that with the right application and waterproof formula, mascara is definitely the way to go!

How to Apply Waterproof Mascara

Now that you’re acquainted with some of waterproof mascara’s common downsides, let’s talk about how to address them! To start, do any lash curling or lifting BEFORE you do anything with the mascara. Lash lifting is usually best done as a cosmetic procedure, but we’re all about DIY lash curling. For the price, this DIY lash curling kit from Amazon is a great place to start if you’re not a professional makeup artist quite yet!
Now let’s get to lash primers. Applying a lash primer has the obvious benefit of providing grip for your mascara, but it’s especially important for someone wearing waterproof mascara! Besides lengthening, volumizing, and declumping your lashes, they also make removing mascara that much easier. If you’re looking for a lash primer that’s both affordable AND high-
quality, you’ll be hard-pressed to do better than the Opening Act Lash Primer from Tarte Cosmetics. But if you’re looking for an excellent cruelty-free brand alternative, the Epic Curl Vegan Lash Primer by KVD Beauty is also a great choice!
Finally, after you’ve curled your lashes and put on some primer, apply one coat of high-quality washable or regular mascara before the waterproof mascara. This does wonders for further volumizing your lashes as well as ensuring the waterproof mascara doesn’t truly stick to the hair itself. For some of the best quality volumizing mascaras around, we’d recommend

The Best Waterproof Mascara Products

Finally, now that you have all the information you need, we can talk about our top picks for the best waterproof mascara. With so many amazing options around, these choices were by no means easy, but you can rest assured that these products are winners for a reason.

Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara by Too Faced – Overall Winner

What’s not to love about this product? Without even getting into the fact that the non-waterproof one is one of the best-selling premium mascaras of all times, there’s just so much that the waterproof one gets right. It’s possibly the best non-clumping waterproof mascara around, and it consequently goes on so easily. Also, the black color is deep and rich, and the hourglass-shaped brush is sure to provide excellent application. As we said, there’s a reason we call this one our All-Star.

Dior Diorshow Waterproof Mascara – Best Statement Maker/False Lashes Replacement

Who doesn’t want their beautiful, bold lashes curled? Dior certainly knows this and thus made THE single best mascara for dramatically gorgeous and curled lashes. The original Diorshow mascara was specifically made for celebs on the red carpet, so it goes without saying that it is bold and long-lasting. The quality is also top-notch and never really clumps or feels dry. But easily the most significant thing about this product is its brush, which is specifically formulated to lift, curl, and fan out your lashes like no other. In other words, if you want to feel like a celeb today, this is your mascara.

Voluminous Lash Paradise  by L’Oreal – Best Budget/Drugstore Option

Running at one-half to one-third the price of many of its competitors, this L’Oreal Mascara packs a serious punch. Basically, we have no complaints at all about this product. This volumizing mascara had our lashes feeling as soft and long as ever, the application was a clump-free cinch, and this product basically stayed on forever., the application was a clump-free cinch, and this product basically stayed on for forever. Oh, and did we mention that the metallic pink packaging looks AMAZING for something at this price point? Simply put, if you’re looking for the best value for an everyday waterproof mascara, this is one’s a winner!

Hypnôse Drama Instant Full Volume by Lancôme – Best Volumizing Option

One of the biggest concerns with waterproof mascara (and mascara in general) is the drying effect, which can sometimes shrink your lashes. Then along came Lancôme with a product and brush that are about as volumizing as a mascara can possibly be. So what’s the deal with this product? Its proprietary formula is made with waxes and vitamins that give it a rich feeling we’d describe as second-to-none. But then, the S-shaped brush swoops in with an effect we’d also describe as one-of-a-kind! It makes complete contact with your lashes in a way that draws the creamy mascara from the base of the lash outwards for a maximally volumizing effect. In other words, buy this product for no other reason than it is legendary at what it does.

Worth The Hype Volumizing Waterproof Mascara NYX Professional Makeup – Longest-Lasting

Some things are meant forever, but we bet you didn’t think mascara would be on that list! That’s right, we found this product to be the longest-lasting of the bunch, and it comes at an amazing price. What else? The brush was soft and did a great job with the application, so we got no clumps when we followed all the right steps. Also, for something this long-lasting, it felt pretty lightweight to the touch. But best of all, this product came off easily without any hassles! That’s right – with this mascara, you can have your cake and eat it too.
What did you think of our roundup of the best waterproof mascara products? Did you have a different opinion about any of these products, or were there some you thought we should have also included on this list? Let us know in the comments or below or on Instagram @successible_life. Better yet, if you want to show off your lovely lashes with some mascara you can’t shut up about, tag us with the hashtag #SuccessibleBeauty for a chance to be reposted!
Successible Life is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.